Web Accessibility Laws in New York
New York is the number one state for federal web accessibility lawsuits, with the New York City Human Rights Law providing even broader protections than federal ADA. If your website is used by New Yorkers, compliance is not optional.
No signup required. Results in under 60 seconds.
New York: The Capital of Web Accessibility Litigation
New York consistently leads all states in federal web accessibility lawsuits, with the Southern District of New York handling more ADA digital accessibility cases than any other federal district. In 2024, over 2,800 federal web accessibility complaints were filed in New York, representing approximately 60% of all such cases nationwide.
Three overlapping laws create a web of compliance obligations: the federal ADA, the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL), and the New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL). The NYCHRL is interpreted more broadly than both the ADA and NYSHRL, covering any business that sells goods or services to New York City residents regardless of physical location.
NYCHRL: The Broadest Accessibility Protections in the US
The New York City Human Rights Law is one of the most expansive anti-discrimination statutes in the country. It covers all "places or providers of public accommodation" and has been interpreted to include websites accessible to NYC residents. Key differences from federal ADA:
- Broader scope: NYCHRL applies to all businesses, regardless of size, that serve NYC residents
- Lower burden of proof: Plaintiffs need only show they were "treated less well" — no need to prove intentional discrimination
- Compensatory and punitive damages: Unlike federal ADA (injunctive relief only), NYCHRL allows monetary damages including punitive awards
- Attorney fee shifting: Prevailing plaintiffs recover attorney fees, incentivizing litigation
The NYSHRL provides statewide protections similar to the NYCHRL, though slightly narrower in scope. Together, these laws make New York the riskiest jurisdiction for web accessibility non-compliance in the United States.
Lawsuit Trends and Notable New York Cases
The Southern District of New York has developed a substantial body of web accessibility case law. Notable cases and trends include:
- Gil v. Winn-Dixie (influential precedent): While a Florida case, it heavily influenced NY courts' treatment of website-only accessibility claims
- Murphy v. Eyebobs LLC (2023): E-commerce retailer settled for $75,000 over inaccessible product pages and checkout flow
- Diaz v. Kroger (2024): Major grocery chain facing class action over inaccessible online ordering system used by millions of NY consumers
Serial plaintiff firms based in New York file the majority of cases. Firms like Mizrahi Kroub and others have filed hundreds of nearly identical complaints, often targeting e-commerce sites, restaurant ordering platforms, and entertainment venues. The average settlement in New York ranges from $15,000 to $100,000 for standard cases, with larger organizations facing settlements well into six figures.
Achieving Compliance for New York Audiences
Given New York's aggressive litigation environment, proactive compliance is essential. Begin with a free CompliScan scan to establish your baseline WCAG 2.1 AA compliance level. Automated tools catch 30-40% of accessibility issues — the very violations most commonly cited in NY lawsuits.
New York-specific compliance priorities:
- E-commerce sites: Product pages, search, filtering, cart, and checkout must be fully keyboard and screen reader accessible
- Restaurant and food delivery: Online ordering, menu browsing, and reservation systems are frequent lawsuit targets
- Government entities: NY state and city agencies must comply with both state law and the federal ADA Title II deadline of April 24, 2026
- Continuous monitoring: New York plaintiffs often revisit sites to document ongoing violations — use CompliScan Shield ($49/mo) for weekly scans
CompliScan's AI-powered fix suggestions help your development team remediate issues quickly. For agencies managing multiple New York-based clients, the Agency plan ($299/mo) covers up to 50 sites with priority scanning and white-label reports.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does New York have more web accessibility lawsuits than any other state?
New York's dominance in web accessibility litigation stems from three factors: the broad NYCHRL and NYSHRL providing strong plaintiff protections, the large concentration of plaintiff-side law firms specializing in accessibility cases, and favorable court interpretations in the Southern District of New York. Over 60% of all federal web accessibility lawsuits are filed in New York.
Does the NYCHRL apply to businesses outside New York City?
Yes. The NYCHRL covers any business that sells goods or services to New York City residents, regardless of where the business is physically located. If your website is accessible to NYC consumers and has accessibility barriers, you may be subject to NYCHRL claims. Given NYC's population of over 8 million, most national e-commerce sites are potentially covered.
What damages can be awarded in New York web accessibility cases?
Under the NYCHRL, plaintiffs can recover compensatory damages, punitive damages, and attorney fees. This is broader than federal ADA, which only provides injunctive relief in private lawsuits. NYSHRL also allows compensatory and punitive damages. Settlements in New York typically range from $15,000 to $100,000, with larger organizations facing significantly higher amounts.
What types of websites are most frequently sued in New York?
E-commerce sites are the most targeted, followed by restaurant and food delivery platforms, entertainment and ticketing websites, healthcare providers, and financial services. Serial plaintiff firms systematically test websites in these categories and file complaints when they find violations. Retail sites with inaccessible product pages and checkout flows are the single largest category.
More Free Tools
Check Your Website Now
Enter your URL below and get a free accessibility report with AI-powered fix suggestions in under 60 seconds.
No signup required. Results in under 60 seconds.